Takeaways From SIPASA’s Debate After a Contentious Campaign Week

By Sheridan Smith

On Friday night, candidates made their cases to students at the School of International and Public Affairs Student Association (SIPASA) 2027 Election Debate, following waves of accusations, rule violations, and withdrawals. The debate turned attention back to the candidates’ promises and platforms. 

“I want to address the elephant in the room,” current SIPASA President Carlene Hunt-Nelson said.

In her opening remarks, Hunt-Nelson acknowledged the controversy surrounding this year’s race before redirecting focus to the candidates. 

“Responsibility belongs to all of us, particularly as students preparing for careers in public service," she continued, before turning to the candidates directly.

"I ask, what's your why? What's your North Star?" Hunt-Nelson said. "Because public service is not always easy."

Sheridan Smith for The Morningside Post

Key Takeaways From the Debate

The debate began with a welcome by Ananya Tomar, Vice President of SIPASA, and Carlene Hunt-Nelson, President of SIPASA. 

Candidates then made their cases by position: 

Dr. Alhad Mulkalwar (Dual Degree Representative)

Aparna Iyer (MPA-DP Representative)

Hyerim Seo (Student Life and Social Chair)

Daphnee Saint Juste (Career and Alumni Affairs Chair)

Durga Sreenivasan (Culture and Inclusion Chair) 

Ferdinando Castro Gonzalez and Mursal Shirzad (University Senator) 

Patrick Brito, Elza Jose, Mahwish Ebrahim, and Ekabouna "Kiki" Joseph (Treasurer)

Antoinette Natasha Benson (General Secretary) 

Lois Antwi (Vice President)

Adam Baltaxe, Kidest Mitiku, and Rose Chehrazi (President)


Main topics that emerged throughout the evening included budget, housing, international students, the dean, and cross-school collaboration. 


Budget

Treasurer candidates all promised more transparent funding. Patrick Brito pledged "equitable, not equal" funding so smaller student organizations aren't competing against larger ones. Elza Jose promised accessibility and stretching student resources further. Mahwish Ebrahim called for more proactive, year-round financial planning rather than funding requests as they come in. Ekabouna "Kiki" Joseph focused on lowering the costs of graduation regalia and student events.

Housing

Housing came up as a top priority across races as well. University Senator candidate Mursal Shirzad pledged to advocate for affordable housing, and presidential candidate Rose Chehrazi said she would prioritize “things that affect standards of living or academics,” naming housing specifically. Kidest Mitiku, another presidential candidate, also said emergency housing is an issue she would address first.

International Students

Support for international students ran through several speeches. Castro Gonzalez said no student should face questions about his or her legal status alone and described working to build legal representation for students. Shirzad drew on her experience leaving Afghanistan and supporting refugee families. Mitiku said visa, citizenship, and employment barriers deserve “everyone’s understanding and not anybody’s assumption.”

The Dean

Rose Chehrazi and Kidest Mitiku, when asked what they would raise first with Dean Keren Yarhi-Milo, both pointed to course registration and access to academic resources, and Adam Baltaxe said he would push the administration for broader inclusion of marginalized voices.

Working With the Rest of Columbia

Presidential candidates also urged closer ties with Columbia’s other schools. Chehrazi proposed joint events with the Law School and easier cross-collaboration. Mitiku called for conferences across schools. Baltaxe said part of his campaign was done at the Law, Journalism and Business schools, adding that cross-campus collaboration is “something we’ve heard a lot about” from SIPASA “but we haven’t seen a lot in actuality.”


Antoinette Natasha Benson (General Secretary) and Aparna Iyer (MPA-DP Representative) could not make it, but each sent in a video, Djamila Kloefer (Vice President) was out sick, and Dhruv Solanki (President) and Abhishek Tiwary (University Senator) had withdrawn before the debate. 

Here’s What Happened Before

Last week, an anonymous source told The Morningside Post that SIPASA was dealing with a number of guideline violations that had occurred, including posters placed outside designated IAB bulletin boards and the use of Columbia, SIPA, or SIPASA logos. Two withdrawal announcements prior to the debate also drew attention from students.

Early Wednesday morning, Dhruv Solanki, whose AI-generated campaign visuals had drawn criticism, announced he was withdrawing from the presidential race in an eight-paragraph message to a SIPA WhatsApp group. He alleged that another candidate and their friends had targeted students' languages and cultures, citing concerns other students had raised with him. The Morningside Post could not independently verify the claims.

Then, on Friday just hours before the debate, Abhishek Tiwary messaged the group to announce his withdrawal from the senator race, saying his “confidence in the neutrality and integrity of [the] SIPASA election was long lost.” 

In response to Tiwary’s eleven-paragraph message, one student wrote: “This the most dramatic election season I’ve ever seen, it’s very irritating.”

“I think it could be irritating to read a long message for people but it’s important to take note of everyone’s concerns,” another replied. 

At the debate, SIPASA Vice President Ananya Tomar gave The Morningside Post  an official statement on behalf of SIPASA addressing the election, thanking the participants, and encouraging students to vote. 

“Regarding the SIPASA 2027 elections, the election committee has conducted this year’s election fairly and impartially. The committee holds no bias towards any candidate, and every step of the process follows the SIPASA Constitution and the election campaign guidelines, which were shared with all the candidates and the student body in advance,” Tomar said. “We thank all the candidates who chose to follow these guidelines, and we encourage every SIPA student to vote.”

Voting is open on CampusGroups now through 11:59 p.m. Monday, November 23. 

The results will be announced by Wednesday at 8p.m.